Nope!
I say this as someone who likes one but not the other (for my own skin tone / vibe. They both look good on you!). Which is not to knock you, but to validate that theyβre different!
boehmei007 on
One leans green one more blue/teal!? I wouldnβt call them dupes but Iβm a weirdo when it comes to stuff like this π€£ if you love bothβ¦ who cares?
roman-de-fauvel on
Same-same but different. One clearly has more blue in it. In fact, Iβd buy the Alchemy one (the bluer one) but not the Mooncat.
simplypolished on
They look different to me! Thankfully π I just got here be dragons in a destash lol
Spice_it_up on
Middle finger is slightly more green
strawberryskis4ever on
These are very different to me!! One is pine green and the other is almost blue/ blue-green!
Theyβre definitely different! One is more green, slightly more earthy, the other leans real.
_annie_bird on
One looks green with a red base, other looks blue-teal with a deep purple base. Totally different! Red-green one gives vampy vibes, blue-indigo one gives summer night vibes.
Refresh-faced on
They are noticeably different in the pictures, with one leaning bluer than the other. If you were in a meeting with me thereβs a good chance Iβd be distracted from whatever the meeting was supposed to be about while I tried to figure out if I was looking at an intentional semi-skittle.
ZirekileFalls on
Same-same but different, mon ami!
curious-spice on
MCβs is way more green. Similar but not dupes. They probably look more similar in real life though
spitfyre on
They look much more different on the nail than in the bottle imo. One is clearly green and the other is clearly blue.
14 Comments
Nope!
I say this as someone who likes one but not the other (for my own skin tone / vibe. They both look good on you!). Which is not to knock you, but to validate that theyβre different!
One leans green one more blue/teal!? I wouldnβt call them dupes but Iβm a weirdo when it comes to stuff like this π€£ if you love bothβ¦ who cares?
Same-same but different. One clearly has more blue in it. In fact, Iβd buy the Alchemy one (the bluer one) but not the Mooncat.
They look different to me! Thankfully π I just got here be dragons in a destash lol
Middle finger is slightly more green
These are very different to me!! One is pine green and the other is almost blue/ blue-green!
Same vibe — different colors. As others have mentioned, one leans more blue and one leans more green. They both look divine on your skin tone π€©
Close but different. I like the Alchemy more.
Theyβre definitely different! One is more green, slightly more earthy, the other leans real.
One looks green with a red base, other looks blue-teal with a deep purple base. Totally different! Red-green one gives vampy vibes, blue-indigo one gives summer night vibes.
They are noticeably different in the pictures, with one leaning bluer than the other. If you were in a meeting with me thereβs a good chance Iβd be distracted from whatever the meeting was supposed to be about while I tried to figure out if I was looking at an intentional semi-skittle.
Same-same but different, mon ami!
MCβs is way more green. Similar but not dupes. They probably look more similar in real life though
They look much more different on the nail than in the bottle imo. One is clearly green and the other is clearly blue.