How to decide???

I love this problem. I became obsessed with Haru Haru Wonder Black Rice Probiotics Barrier Essence as a milky toner, used it down to the last drop. My first HG. I saw the Tirtir Milk Skin Toner at Marshall’s and snagged it just to try. I initially didn’t think I’d like it that much, as the texture seemed much more watery than Haru Haru. But man it feels SO good on! My question is how do you go about deciding which of two really great yet similar products you’ll focus on? Again, such an awesome problem! 🙂

My skin: normal with a little dehydration and slight redness. Not sensitive or acne prone. Also using tret. I like using Haru Haru and Tirtir am and pm.