I have been using this mascara for a few years now and I bought a new one in January. I bought it from Amazon from the same seller that I have previously purchased from but it feels completely different.

I have pin straight hair and my lashes really struggle to stay curled, this mascara is the only thing I have found that works so far.

The brush is a different shape and the formula feel different. I have posted a picture of the new one and the old one for comparison. My lashes have been straightening out very quickly when the old one would keep a curl all day and the new one has been smudging very easily. Has there been a formula change? Or have I just got a dodgy one and should return it and order a new one?

Thank you for your help.

by Ok_Comparison525

Share.

2 Comments

  1. Ok_Comparison525 on

    It wonโ€™t let me edit but if anyone has any suggestions on mascaras that are waterproof and keep a curl all day for pin straight lashes. My lashes curl (if I use heat) and will stay for a bit but do drop. This mascara seems to be the only thing that keeps them curled but if anyone knows any mascaras that work better please let me know!

  2. Amazon is notorious for mixing inventory so I wouldnโ€™t buy cosmetics from them, even if the seller is reputable. Buy from online retailers who have a good reputation, like yesstyle.

Leave A Reply