sheer lip tints/oils

I bought Innisfree bloody chocolate lip oil (pictured above) years ago and fell in love. It was the perfect balance for me. It wasn’t super pigmented but left with a kind of dusty-red/pink colour underneath. I honestly can’t tell if it is warm or cool and don’t know if I’m warm or cool, but I have a swatch picture below. The above isn’t my swatch but my product is bare bones now and has less pigment than it did 😅 I have tried a bunch of alternatives and haven’t found anything quite like it since it was discontinued. What is everyone trying for more sheer formulas? I’ve tried:

– Rom&nd water glasting tint and gloss and juicy lasting tint- too pigmented
– Dinto blur glowy lip tint. Great, but still more pigmented than I want.
– espoir lip tint shine- super pigmented
– laka in unsweet berry. – awesome but more purple than I wanted.

I’ve tried a number more but can’t remember the exact names as of now. I haven’t really explored glosses and haven’t seen any similar lip oils on yes style. Hoping someone may know of some similar formula/colour than is more sheer.

Hmm how about the Fwee 3D Voluming Gloss that comes in 30% and 70% versions of each shade? The 30% might be sheer enough for you. If you’re open to lip balms it might be worth checking out “men’s” lip balms, which has much sheerer colours.