Its been 84 years… no really, I’ve had the replacement waiting for a YEAR. First finished black eyeliner pencil EVER.

Manhattan endless stay waterproof gel eyeliner in Black

I’ve had this thing for so long, I’m pretty sure I graduated high school with it. It’s the only liner I’ve ever finished that was not a liquid, broke off, or otherwise lost/tossed.

It was used mostly for the undereye, so it lasted forever, but I’ve recently used it for the upper lid line & wing too to just finish it already.

Its dry, it skips, and you have to hold your lid in place for it to line well. But it’s ancient, so that’s that.

A year ago, in Feb 23, I got this mini Pat McGrath permagel liner in a set on sale with a mini mascara for 11€ (or was it 13?). Back then I thought mine was on its last leg! I got another full-size of the PML liner in a set too, honestly I may give that away seeing how long they last. That one’s a pencil tho, not a twist up.

The other items here are my already panned and repressed bronzer, highlight, and the eyeshadow I’m working on. You may see them again soon.