ILNP’s official swatch photos highlight the red color more, kb shimmer’s main swatch angle highlights the coppery shift more. In person they’re identical.
The bottle shapes of round vs square also make them look more different than they are because the differing amount of angled glass highlights different amounts of shift. (See below)
I was quite upset when they arrived but that’s what I get for not seeking out additional photos beyond the main swatches on the store sites.
d0va13 on
I think in general plain multichromes with the same type of shift are identical between brands.
theSpookyMouse on
Yes, I have both. I haven’t tested it out on my hands in the summer sunlight. I don’t think obsidian has as strong of a shift to the yellow/gold, but haven’t been able to confirm.
4 Comments
Polish with Rae has [an excellent video](https://youtu.be/AbDzT2pPZqQ) where she did swatches of both of these and compared them!
Yes it is 100% identical.
https://preview.redd.it/nxsx70l2xf2g1.jpeg?width=3024&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=e66cab1453f96193186128b0b4f849f37e82cf8e
ILNP’s official swatch photos highlight the red color more, kb shimmer’s main swatch angle highlights the coppery shift more. In person they’re identical.
The bottle shapes of round vs square also make them look more different than they are because the differing amount of angled glass highlights different amounts of shift. (See below)
I was quite upset when they arrived but that’s what I get for not seeking out additional photos beyond the main swatches on the store sites.
I think in general plain multichromes with the same type of shift are identical between brands.
Yes, I have both. I haven’t tested it out on my hands in the summer sunlight. I don’t think obsidian has as strong of a shift to the yellow/gold, but haven’t been able to confirm.