These Benefit Creaseless Cream Shadows were discontinued YEARS ago but I loved them so much and the birds on the lids made me so happy. Somehow I ended up with two of the Tattletale shade. (This isn’t even the latest version of the packaging for this product before it was discontinued!)
I’ve repeatedly revived these over the past decade, typically using MAC Fix+, but the revivals are going worse and worse and I might be making peace with these having reached the end of their lives.
My favorite shades were Tattletale (top, 2nd and 3rd from right), Birthday Suit (top, 2nd from left), and RSVP (top, 3rd from right). Busy Signal (bottom, 2nd from left) was first to seriously dry out, and Ice Shot (bottom middle) stayed creamy the longest with the least intervention. But even it is coming out patchy when revived now.
Anybody else had or loved these? Is anybody still working on them?
by ArganBomb
2 Comments
Ugh, sorry for the typo above, but RSVP is the top, 3rd from left (not right).
I loved these! Especially RSVP. I think I have one buried in a drawer somewhere that you’re inspiring me to find and see if it’s still usable.