Panned Nyx and Saie

Completely panned the Nyx Bare With Me concealer and Saie Moonglow. I’ve already repurchased Nyx but I’m on the fence with Saie.
Just some clarity:

1. I have combo-dry skin. I get oily in my t-zone but have dry skin around my face.
2. Nyx is the best concealer of all time. RARELY creased. Worked well with any other product; whether it be a primer, powder, or foundation.
3. Saie made me oilier towards the end of the day but never separated.