Just sharing some swatches of Lilybyred items! I've got some Velvet Tints, Bloody Liar Coating Tint, and the one Juicy Liar Water Tint. Honestly not sure yet if there are very meaningful differences in the formulas–they all seem pretty similar, except the Velvet Tints are more matte-ish than glossy.
They all stain very well. I'm pretty pleased with that. So far I have only tried wearing the Bloody Liar in Strong Cherry and the Juicy Liar in Blackberry Tequila. The former is not as deep as I thought it was going to be judging by their color chart, but the Blackberry Tequila is THERE. If you are looking for a very deep vampy color, I'd recommend Blackberry Tequila! The gloss lasts surprisingly well and it has worn down into a very pretty stain over the course of the day, which included eating lunch and sipping from a straw.
I'm also including Lilybyred's color charts so you can see where the colors I have fall according to them.
The last picture is just what they look like after having sat on my arm for about 5 minutes and been rubbed a few times with a tissue. As you can see, Blackberry Tequila is VERY staining. Innocent Apple is probably the most staining.
I have neutral-cool, light-medium skin.
by Catloaver