Haunted By the Moonlight vs. BKL It Doesn’t Know Any Better But You Do

I picked up this BKL hoping it would be a passable dupe of By The Moonlight, and then the actual BTM came back in stock, so I got to compare them! And they're definitely not dupes. Haunted (on top) has a finer magnetic pigment, more muted colors, and darker background; BKL (on the bottom) has more sparkle, and the magnetic pigment is peachier with a lime-green shift at a strong angle. Both beautiful polishes, but the Haunted is the one that made my husband go "Ooh, what is THAT?"