Magnetic polish issue?

Hi all,

I ordered "Tannins In The Leaves" from Death Valley Nails because of the cat eye effect but after using three generic magnetic wands off Amazon, I'm stuck with this weird coppery shimmer effect instead of what's show on the website. I used three coats and tried magnetizing each one while still wet per their website's instructions.

I used Nail Tek's Strengthener polish as a base coat and then Essie's Speed Setter top coat after trying and failing to get that cat eye effect.

Would a branded magnetic wand work better? Or did I just get a dud?

Thanks!