I used up this lip liner from NYX. The formula is a little bit drag/tug when you apply on the lips but it stays pretty well. This shade is darker than my actual lip color pretty much and it pairs well whenever I use red lip tint. However, it is not my absolute favorite and I noticed the formula dry out pretty fast so I would not buy it again. I will give it a 3.3/5
by NhuPear_Boba