I first bought the one on the left, but it was during my vacation overseas and I could not repurchase this brand back in America. So I bought a second palette from Ulta that I thought matched it as much as possible. I kinda just keep the first one as a souvenir/memento now while I pan the new one, though I prefer the creaminess of the shimmer of the palette on the left as you can tell.
Left: Pony Energy Adore Velvet Nine Color Eyeshadow Palette 738-602
Right: Colourpop eyeshadow palette in Nude Mood
by OkAccountant5204